Oh dear.
A few years back when we still lived in the UK, a company there came out with a device called the Mosquito Alarm. The sole function of the alarm is to emit a high frequency sound.
The thing is, this frequency can only be heard by people under the age of 25. This may sound weird but your hearing deteriorates as you get older, so you’re unable to hear high frequencies of this kind.
Someone had the supposedly genius idea that creating a device that emits this sound would be a great way of solving the “youth problem”. Stick the alarm somewhere that young people like to hang out and voila – problem solved.
Except the problem isn’t solved. And now it’s apparently made its way to Australia.
Here’s why the Mosquito Alarm sucks:
1) Discriminatory
The first reason the Mosquito Alarm sucks is because it discriminates against young people. When it’s only people under the age of 25 who get affected by this high pitched buzzing, it’s discriminating against young people – including those who have done nothing wrong.
If there was a frequency that only people aged over 75 could hear, would I be justified in creating a device that caused hearing pain for them, simply because I generalized old people as “a problem”? Or would this rightfully be seen as discrimination and ageism?
It works both ways – this is just another example of casual ageism against youth.
2) It’s not always youth who are the problem
I can understand why some businesses want to do something about anti-social behavior outside their store. Having managed a convenience store myself in the past, I know how frustrating it can be to have people behaving obnoxiously outside.
The thing is, it’s not only youth that do this. Adults could be just as obnoxious. Adults were just as likely to come in and shoplift. It was an adult that stole a pile of newspapers from outside our store and used them to set fire to the pub opposite us.
3) It’s not only teens that are affected
Although the Mosquito Alarm is primarily aimed at hurting the eardrums of teens, it can affect anyone under the age of 25. This is fine for young people old enough to walk away by themselves. But what about babies? Their hearing is affected too and they can’t do anything about it if they can’t talk or walk.
4) It moves “the problem” along
If a group of youth congregate somewhere and then the Mosquito Alarm is turned on, all that’s going to happen is that they’ll move elsewhere. Besides……
5) What’s wrong with hanging out?
When I was a teen, me and my friends used to all hang out in the village where we lived. There was nothing else to do, so we’d hang out in the park, at the bus stop, by the sports pavilion, etc.
We weren’t obnoxious, we didn’t vandalize anything and we weren’t causing trouble for anybody, but I’m sure people walking by would have looked down on us as a problem. Some adults may have wanted to put up Mosquito Alarms if they were around back then, but why? We were just hanging out – it’s what young people do and it doesn’t mean they’re doing anything threatening.
6) It reinforces stereotypes
This alarm, and especially reporting on it, reinforces stereotypes of youth in general being a problem. Youth are yobs, vandals and when they get together it means they’re in gangs.
Don’t get me wrong, I know that there are youth who are gang members or who will vandalize property. But the media is always so quick to write a story that fits into the narrative of young people being troublemakers, rather than focusing on all those youth who make a difference.
7) It doesn’t solve anything
Here’s the kicker. The Mosquito Alarm doesn’t solve anything. As we mentioned in number 4, all it does is move young people along. If they’re doing some kind of criminal behavior, there’s a good chance they’ll just move and do it elsewhere.
So instead of just sticking our heads in the sand, how about we as communities do something about it?
Get to know the young people that are being deemed as troublemakers.
Build a relationship with them.
Find out why they’re behaving the way they are.
Set up a youth club, sports club or something else that gives them something to do and develop in a positive way.
And stop just seeing young people as problem teenagers.
Question: What are your thoughts on the Mosquito Alarm? We’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.
You can also connect with us by:
- Signing up to receive our posts via email
- Following us on Twitter
- Liking us on Facebook
- Signing up to our RSS feed